There is no single formula for a perfect offer. The right number comes from a mix of comparable sales, property condition, and what is happening in the micro-market right now. Use this step-by-step approach to land on a price you feel good about and a strategy that fits the situation.
Start with a real budget
Know your ceiling before you look at houses. Use a current mortgage pre-approval and include closing costs, moving costs, and a small buffer. If you plan to compete above recent sales, keep an “appraisal gap” cushion in case the lender values the home lower than your offer.
Pull the right comparable
Not all comps are equal. Prioritize the closest matches in the same pocket and school area over older or farther sales.
For freehold homes, match by:
lot size and frontage
number of beds and baths
finished basement, separate entrance, parking type
age and quality of renovations
For condos, match by:
building and line if possible
interior square footage, parking and locker
monthly maintenance fees and what they include
exposure, floor height, and amenities
Use the last 60 to 90 days where possible. If the market is moving, adjust older comps up or down to reflect current conditions.
Adjust for condition and layout
Cosmetics are easy to change. Systems and structure are not. Give weight to roofs, windows, wiring, plumbing, and HVAC age. Value a functional layout, natural light, ceiling height, and storage. Confirm that finished spaces are done with permits where required. Legal status matters for basement suites and additions.
Read today’s market on that street
Micro-market context shifts the price you can win with. Look at:
days on market for similar homes right now
the sale-to-list pattern in the area
whether the listing has an offer date or is “offers any time”
showing traffic and how many buyers you may face
If a home is under-listed with an offer date, your target is the true market value from recent sales, not the list price. If a home has been sitting without an offer date, you may have room to negotiate.
Decide on your range
Build a simple range with three points:
fair value based on the best comps
a conservative entry number that still shows you are serious
a stretch number you would be comfortable paying if competition is strong
Your “walk-away” number is the one above which you would rather keep looking. Write it down before you hear what other buyers are doing.
Balance price with terms
Sellers consider the whole offer, not just the top line. A strong deposit, a closing date that fits the seller, and clean conditions can improve your position. Use conditions strategically:
financing and inspection for freeholds
status certificate review for condos
In heavy competition, shorten timelines rather than removing protection you truly need.
Watch the appraisal and insurance details
If your offer is higher than recent sales, the appraisal may come in low. Be ready with extra funds or adjust your offer strategy. For older homes, understand what insurers will ask for on wiring, plumbing, or roof age. Smooth financing depends on both.
Special notes for condos
Maintenance fees affect market value and your monthly budget. A low fee is not always better if it under-funds the reserve. Review the status certificate for the reserve fund, insurance, upcoming work, and any special assessments. Parking, lockers, and view lines can swing value more than you expect.
Special notes for freeholds
Exterior water management and electrical systems are common swing factors in Toronto’s older stock. Solid grading, updated wiring, and a dry basement justify stronger pricing than dated systems with risk.
Put it together on paper
List your three best comps with brief adjustments. Write your fair value, your conservative entry, and your stretch number. Confirm your walk-away and any conditions you need. From there, choose the combination of price and terms that gives you the best chance to win without regret.
The bottom line
A smart offer price comes from facts, not feelings. Let recent sales set the guardrails, let the property’s condition and layout refine the number, and let today’s market decide how bold you need to be. When the plan is clear, you can move quickly and confidently.
If you want help pricing a specific home, call (416) 347-3686 or book a consult. I will review the comps, the micro-market, and your financing details so you can make the right offer with confidence.
Comments:
Post Your Comment: